recentpopularlog in

academia

« earlier   
When the Revolution Came for Amy Cuddy - The New York Times
As a young social psychologist, she played by the rules and won big: an influential study, a viral TED talk, a prestigious job at Harvard. Then, suddenly, the rules changed.
science  academia  statistics 
2 days ago by nathanen
When the Revolution Came for Amy Cuddy - The New York Times
Another article on the replication crisis fallout and some of the related drama. It's possibly overblown in some ways but sigh at the "take a side" dynamic described. Plus bonus veneer of jealousy and possibly sexism.
statistics  psychology  replication-crisis  academia 
2 days ago by mr_stru
When the Revolution Came for Amy Cuddy - The New York Times
Since 2011, a methodological reform movement has been rattling the field, raising the possibility that vast amounts of research, even entire subfields, might be unreliable. Up-and-coming social psychologists, armed with new statistical sophistication, picked up the cause of replications, openly questioning the work their colleagues conducted under a now-outdated set of assumptions. The culture in the field, once cordial and collaborative, became openly combative, as scientists adjusted to new norms of public critique while still struggling to adjust to new standards of evidence.

More often than not, those decisions — always seemingly justified as a way of eliminating noise — conveniently strengthened the findings’ results. The field (hardly unique in this regard) had approved those kinds of tinkering for years, underappreciating just how powerfully they skewed the results in favor of false positives, particularly if two or three analyses were underway at the same time. The three eventually wrote about this phenomenon in a paper called “False-Positive Psychology,” published in 2011. “Everyone knew it was wrong, but they thought it was wrong the way it’s wrong to jaywalk,” Simmons recently wrote in a paper taking stock of the field. “We decided to write ‘False-Positive Psychology’ when simulations revealed it was wrong the way it’s wrong to rob a bank.”

For a moment, the scientist allowed the human element to factor into how he felt about his email response to that paper. “I wish,” he said, “I’d had the presence of mind to pick up the phone and call Amy.”
science  psychology  academia  methodology 
2 days ago by craniac

Copy this bookmark:





to read